Washington DC
New York
Toronto
Distribution: (800) 510 9863
Press ID
  • Login
Edinburg Post
No Result
View All Result
Thursday, November 19, 2026
  • World • Politics
  • Business • Finance
  • Culture • Entertainment
  • Health • Food
  • Lifestyle • Travel
  • Science • Technology
  • Latest • Trending
  • World • Politics
  • Business • Finance
  • Culture • Entertainment
  • Health • Food
  • Lifestyle • Travel
  • Science • Technology
  • Latest • Trending
No Result
View All Result
Edinburg Post
No Result
View All Result
Home World • Politics

Supreme Court may extend free-speech rights to online stalkers

by Edinburg Post Report
April 19, 2023
in World • Politics
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

WASHINGTON — 

The Supreme Court heard a free-speech case on Wednesday and sounded ready to make it much harder to prosecute alleged online stalkers who repeatedly send unwanted and harassing messages that leave the victim upset and frightened.

At issue is whether prosecutors must prove the online stalker intended to make true threats.

Coles Whalen, a Colorado musician, said she quit performing in public after receiving menacing messages over two years from a man she never met.

“The thousands of unstable messages sent to me were life threatening and life altering,” she said. “I was terrified that I was being followed and could be hurt at any moment; I had no choice but to step back from my dream, a music career that I had worked very hard to build.”

Some messages invited her to “come out for coffee.” Others referred to seeing her in public. A few sounded angry. “Die. Don’t need you.”

She told friends the messages were “weird” and “creepy,” and she repeatedly blocked them on Facebook. But the messages continued, and she complained to police.

Billy Ray Counterman was prosecuted for stalking and causing emotional distress. His defense attorneys said he was “delusional” and suffered from mental illness, but he did not intend to threaten Whalen.

He was convicted by a jury and given four and half years in prison, in part because he had an earlier conviction for sending threats online.

The Supreme Court agreed to hear his appeal, and most of the justices — conservatives and liberal — sounded sympathetic to his 1st Amendment claim.

Washington attorney John P. Elwood, representing Counterman, urged the court to rule that prosecutors must prove the stalking defendant had a “specific intent” to threaten the recipient of his messages.

He argued the 1st Amendment has been understood to protect the freedom of speech, except when a person makes a “true threat” of violence. In this case, he said, the government was not required to show Counterman intended to threaten the musician.

“Criminalizing misunderstanding is especially dangerous in an age when so much communication occurs on social media,” he said.

Colorado Atty. Gen. Philip J. Weiser argued the danger flows in the other direction. Cyberstalking can “cause life-changing harm,” he said.

“Requiring specific intent in cases of threatening stalkers would immunize those who are untethered from reality,” Weiser added. “It would also allow devious stalkers to escape accountability by insisting that they meant nothing by their harmful statements.”

In Counterman’s case, Whalen “didn’t know what he looked like. Do you have to wait until the person engages in violence?” he said.

The attorneys differed on the impact of a ruling that requires proof of the speaker’s intent. Elwood said it would not affect many cases, but the Colorado attorney said it would make prosecutions more difficult.

The court will issue a decision in the case of Counterman vs. Colorado by late June.

Leave Comment

EDITOR'S PICK

Prep talk: Freshman Charlie Adams leads St. Bonaventure into 2A basketball final

Want to help a friend find love? Give a PowerPoint presentation at this L.A. dating event

Vote count for California governor, L.A. mayor could be painfully slow. Don’t expect ‘instant gratification’

Dipa Karmakar Banned For 21 Months For Use Of Prohibited Substance: International Testing Agenc

EP NEWSROOM

Malek Bentchikou

Unlocking Success: The Journey of Malek Bentchikou, a 23-Year-Old Algerian Trader

Former Dolton officer hired by Munster police despite ‘traumatic’ incidents at past job

Mia Sorety

Mia Sorety: Houston’s Rising Fitness Influencer Inspires Thousands to Embrace a Healthier Lifestyle

Grayslake data center could become largest county development; water and energy concerns remain

Union Township residents show up in force to protest data centers proposed for rural community

Edinburg Post

© 2025 Edinburg Post or its affiliated companies.

Navigate Site

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Contact

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • World • Politics
  • Business • Finance
  • Culture • Entertainment
  • Health • Food
  • Lifestyle • Travel
  • Science • Technology
  • Latest • Trending

© 2025 Edinburg Post or its affiliated companies.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In